Crowdsourcing Is Poison to the Design Community

Crowdsourcing Is Poison to the Design Community

Pawning sites like Crowdspring, Bootb.com, GeniusRocket, Worth1000.com and 99designs off as “crowdsourcing design networks” is covering the wolf in sheep’s clothing. It’s one thing to run a design contest online – a true contest where there’s an objective, a prize or prizes, and most importantly a singularity of purpose.

sheep

Don’t get stuck moshing around for the scraps

It’s a completely different thing to build a contest factory that milks a large group of eager and hungry individuals for their best ideas with no promise of compensation. It, simply, is against design business ethics. This is spec work, plain and simple.

If you are a hungry designer, I promise, this will not keep you fed well. They say that they “pay cash for real work”, when in fact the client will pay a pre-determined amount of money (in other words, a budget set by someone who might have no clue what design budgets should be) to one (or more) winner(s). This is not “work”, this is a circus. This will not create a career for but a few people. Perhaps it’s a short means to an end for some people keeping food on the plate, but this it completely counter to the ethical guidelines for designers.

What these sites will do is drive the prices clients pay for design down, and allow companies to receive tons of unpaid-for design comps. Companies have an eager audience and can set low “prizes” for the winner, but are receiving tens if not hundreds of submissions – while they only own the winner’s concepts, do you think that they don’t take and incorporate other ideas they see in unselected submissions?

Hopefully you’re able to find work. Hopefully you don’t have to resort to throwing away great ideas for a chance to sit at the client’s table. I’m not judging anyone – times are tough and work is much more scarce than in years past – but I have little problem judging the companies who have the money to be paying proper rates and budgets to designers.

While the design contests will continue for sure, I hope that more designers take a long, hard look at their involvement in such practices. It runs counter to all of the groundwork designers have been laying for decades.

I pray the tides change, or who knows, in the future we all could be making our living through such competitions. With a bit of despair, I feel like I truly understand the feeling behind Murrow’s famous “Good night, and good luck.”

If you enjoyed this article, please consider joining (or starting) the conversation by leaving a comment below. Thank you kindly.
Greg is the Director of Creative Services for digital entertainment rising star, DEFY Media. A career creative, Greg has worked for various agencies in Southern California since 1997, and also ran his own small digital shop in Pasadena, Go Farm (with partner, Brian Jeremy Kupetz). He's led and designed projects for: West Coast Choppers, Epitaph Records, Warner Bros., Fox Searchlight, American Airlines, Kawasaki, and Atlantic Records, to name a few. He's manned his post as Creative Director with DEFY Media (previously Break Media) since 2009. Away from work, he cooks and bakes daily. At the center of his world are his three wonderful children, and his gorgeous and talented wife, Folake Kuye Huntoon (a creative director / editor in the fashion industry).
8 comments
Jon
Jon

Threadless certainly set the trend for this if you ask me.

Caleb Chang
Caleb Chang

My old boss once said, "if a client engages you because of price, they will leave you for the same." I believe the clients, for the most part, who participate in crowdsourcing design either 1. don't value design and are opportunists that want something for almost nothing or 2. really want to put an idea out there to the community. Does it devalue what we as designers do? To me, the jury's out on that one. To me, this is a similar argument to user-generated content. I find it fascinating to see the collective creativity that is out there and there are certainly pros that participate. The clients that truly value the design process, will pay the moneys to get it done through the traditional channels.

StrawberryTech
StrawberryTech

@Caleb Chang I also think there is a 3rd reason: Some people are genuinely desperate/broke people who don't know how to do the designs themselves. 

  • grannie fuck pictures
  • free clasy porn videos
  • grandma loves young girls tube
  • naked teen butts
  • free mature blonde porn tubes
  • Teenage breast pictures
  • facial tatoo on girls
  • beautiful young girls sucking cock
  • little girls big black dicks
  • pga tour wife pics
  • sex young amateur
  • free lesbian porn stars
  • sexy hot girls having sex
  • submitted mature movies
  • free young trnsexual porn
  • Miss teen beauty pageant
  • young students home sex videos
  • dumb asian girls
  • free topless biker babes galleries
  • asian schoolgorls tubeporn
  • dys girl black lab sticker oval
  • Fotos de vaginas
  • d hardcore teens
  • girl flashing movie
  • vintage busty tits videos
  • jucy pussy videos
  • vintage anal pics free big cocks
  • little girl panty porn
  • small penis in pussy
  • movies of girls fucking
  • very young pussy pics
  • teens fuck on train
  • sex with my boss pictures
  • two young girls dressing up tube
  • porn xxx amatuer babe
  • nicole english redhead porn black
  • tits beach video
  • free hyapatia lee black sex
  • Naked teen swimming
  • japanese mom teaches young son
  • old man sucking pussy
  • girl measures boys penis picture
  • wife bachelorette party
  • naked moms i wanna fuck video
  • elementary schoolgirls porn
  • facial paralysis pictures
  • porn live webcams free
  • sex aict group rolla mo
  • girls getting naked
  • brazillian butt lift surgery pictures
  • pussy sewing movie
  • Super black boobs
  • recieving oral sex with herpes
  • rate petite girls nice body
  • anal teen porn streaming
  • filipino mature videos
  • erotic lingerie galleries
  • painfull first anal fuck
  • russsian teen sex
  • natural teen amateur
  • Cute emo girl porn
  • girl getting naked
  • asian big tit gallery
  • tania spice orgasm video
  • Eating shaved pussy
  • music video boys watching topless mother
  • free costa rican pussy pics
  • big anal movie xnxx
  • dys little naked girls
  • nurse fuck video
  • Naked girl stripper
  • oree porn movies
  • blonde teens riding
  • hot asian american sexy
  • free sex movies desi
  • Hot girl tattos
  • keisha pussy pictures
  • free amateur adult sex anal
  • naked virgin teenagers videos
  • mature large fat lesbian
  • sarah vandalla bikini pics
  • Nude asian pics
  • pictures of tits and pussy
  • young asian girl galleries
  • bikini big ass gallery
  • Cum swapping teen movie free
  • ben porn videos not pitchers
  • teen age girls shoe foot sex
  • videos of black girls having sex
  • downloads of free video porn
  • sexe amateur pipe
  • jennifer walcott naked videos
  • tits anal sex
  • dirty teen girl porn
  • japan sex mature women
  • black girls peeing on girl
  • female orgasm pussy
  • real jiggly hoe sex videos
  • dildo in black pussy
  • black porn no fee no charge
  • cosette porn videos
  • Young sex images
  • Perfect body tits
  • pictures of pornstar cherry fluff
  • orgasm screaming lesbian
  • free naked blond teen picturs
  • foursome group sex video free
  • sweet teen sextape
  • teenage girls sexual fantasies
  • blonde college girl sucks cock comic
  • big girl diaper change movie
  • Xxl big ass
  • horny teens xxx
  • Huge boob models
  • Sexy arbic girls
  • black teen booty girl
  • best ebony dvd xxx
  • Elisha cuthbert sex scenes
  • hardcore ipod porn
  • anal sex and prostate health
  • amateur adult video upload adult
  • introducing girlfriend to anal sex
  • sexy hot bikini brides
  • japanese porn shaved pussy
  • black mature fuckers
  • sex video women using rabbit vibrator
  • Lesbian nude hot
  • free videos anal pain
  • xena black pornstar
  • christina ricci black snake moan pics
  • ass licked while fucking videos
  • young black gorl takes big dick
  • Chinese teens naked
  • outdoor fucking porn videos cock sucking
  • polish teen gallery
  • play with jenn blowjob video
  • japan bum sex
  • Wild sex vids
  • Hot girls shitting
  • anal sex insructional
  • girl eats creampie from ass
  • freeamateur natural breasts videos
  • young shemale tubes
  • Deshi hot girl
  • amateur video daily
  • virgin teeny pussy fuck
  • fuck young pre
  • keeley hazell topless gallery
  • Adrienne bailon naked pics
  • free amateur hien cam sex
  • aa tits naked pics
  • dick in hot ass
  • naked girls sexy
  • girl farting videos
  • girl having period porn
  • free hardcore seduction movies
  • pussy eating porn rawtube
  • hardcore nudist family pics
  • dirty sexy porn hot ebony milf
  • Teen red panties
  • monster cock porn galleries
  • party girls vip
  • horny slutty blonde teens videos
  • ebony girls white
  • petite tiny teens fucking
  • barbie college girl porn hub
  • transexual ass eating
  • wife sex dares
  • pink sexy girl
  • big butt in nylons fucked video
  • isla fisher naked pics
  • Indian sex live movies
  • football movie with girl qb
  • how to make homemade pussy video
  • picture of black man ass
  • red hot babes pics
  • jaegermeister party girls
  • hot black girls getting fucked videos
  • japan porn mp free
  • sexy asian girlr
  • white cock black wives
  • cute butt gallery sexy
  • cassitty free porn videos and photos
  • Big ass nylon
  • picture of toby keiths wife
  • teen track girls bloomers
  • free black tgirls video
  • mature blue tube videos
  • hardcore ii pictures
  • little girls fuck torrent
  • retro porn movies free
  • porn black booty
  • sexy girl and boy sex stories
  • Sexy gymnastic girl
  • same sex couples in canada
  • girls feel each others boobs
  • cute blonde sexy puffy nipples
  • very tiny tits galleries
  • free erotic forbiden sex vidios
  • big ass pussy lips of celeberties
  • atl black fuck
  • mature saggy boobs video
  • mom facial videos
  • ebony dirty sex
  • tall thin italian fuck video
  • young breasts vagina
  • cum shots on teen girl faces
  • xhamster yery young fuck
  • teen girl body changes pics
  • young chicks small titts
  • black amateur sex porn
  • white wife bred black amateur
  • Chubby teen booty
  • wife in revealing clothing pictures
  • wife black thug
  • small girl movies for free
  • ilegal naked young girls
  • Naked beach pussy
  • asian boob vids
  • pigtail blonde teen sex
  • girls virginity lost on video
  • older wife fucking younger men
  • taxi girls movie
  • completly free webcam girls
  • little teeny pussy
  • slutload mature black pussy
  • teen girl in chaning room
  • hot kerala girls pics
  • Naked girls metacafe
  • hardcore porn pics milf
  • young teen boy screwing older woman
  • couples having sex in the car
  • girls sucking large tits
  • my dy fucked my pussy
  • girl dancing in bikini
  • big cock mature sex
  • free teen sex vedio
  • porn videos now
  • jayden jaymes porn movies
  • twink sex with mature
  • janet mason pornstar free movies
  • Rani mukherjee nude video
  • hot chicks licking pussy
  • video erotic real
  • hot girl takes a bath naked
  • naked young casting couch
  • black internal cum xxx
  • big black dick in tight pussy
  • young pre girl
  • teen boy free videos
  • yourcaitlynn blowjob full video
  • free videos of amateur handjobs
  • hair highlights teen girl
  • jimmy neutron porn movies
  • he tied her virgin pussy cock
  • free mature anal movies
  • black pussy cuckholds
  • little young vids
  • blonde teen pussy fat beard sex
  • young girls knicker wetting
  • slutloads young teens
  • digital dream girls gallery
  • video fuck ass girl xnxx
  • video fuck son
  • odessa girls topless
  • benefit of oral sex
  • stani pure beauty mag galleries
  • sex blow job cum fuck
  • Kate hudson nude photos
  • Sex and lucia full movie
  • amayure pussy slutload
  • drunk chick ass gallery
  • pussy bdsm electric redtube
  • old young naked
  • newcastle amateur wives
  • free hardcore office pics
  • wife and dauter amatue video
  • Hot nude pornstar
  • bb granny sex videos
  • very young teen girls little
  • super young girls
  • Vintage girls porn
  • teen girl halloween pirate costume
  • mature dy galleries
  • Huge tits in tight shirts
  • japanese giantess porn
  • black womensex videos
  • sexy sling bikini pics
  • streaming porn videos jenna jameson
  • home made teen nude movies
  • free extream sex video
  • anal fucking free videos
  • white anal milfs videos
  • naked porn tubr
  • aged mature spreading legs pics
  • wifes first time anal
  • asian sex rooms
  • free erotic sex porn stories
  • gum job sex xxx toothless image
  • outdoor naked boy pics
  • girls first orgasm video
  • fuck black female bodybuilders
  • sex with mature wives
  • emo boy porn pics
  • amateur videos yuvutu
  • picture gabriella montez naked
  • Hot young college girls
  • Pussy licking fun
  • hardcore porn streaming videos
  • my girl friend blow job video
  • Outdoor interracial sex
  • blonde girlfriend slutload
  • free full lenght sex movies online
  • sonic porn sex xxx
  • nude ass galleries
  • free hardcore se movies
  • Sex bed girl
  • vulgar porn video
  • mature home sex videos
  • Videos big breast
  • Oral sex is the new goodnight kiss by sharlene azam
  • young girls insest video
  • hot young virgins get penitrated
  • pictures of jemma jameson pussy
  • japan black tatooing
  • free online sex movies baseball bat
  • suck a dick dry
  • power girl porn
  • babes free video online
  • anais alexander interracial sex video
  • vintge japanese black glass beads
  • mature tit full vids
  • euro model photographer fuck video
  • virgin pussy pictures hymen
  • naked teen girl australia
  • asian school girls sex pictures
  • you porn young sluts
  • Sex picture story
  • small girls sex free vedio
  • teen girl pantys